How to Choose the Right Digital Video Camcorder
Before you jump into the world of digital
video, there are a few things we want to share
with you about choosing the right digital video
camcorder. The following will explain the
difference between analog and digital video,
choosing a video format, choosing your tripod,
deciding what kind of user you are and different
factors such as lens quality, pixels, and audio
options when actually purchasing your camcorder.
Understanding
Digital Video
First, let’s talk about the difference
between analog and digital video and why analog
is no longer an acceptable form of video if you
are living in modern times! Analog video uses an
electrical signal to capture images on magnetic
tape. A digital video signal is a pattern of 1’s
and 0’s that represent the video image. There is
no variation in the original signal once it’s
captured, and the image does not lose any of its
original sharpness or clarity---it’s an exact
copy of the original. Due to the major advances
in digital technology, it is highly recommended
by HomeMovie.Com that you choose digital video
and not analog video. Here’s why:
- The quality of digital video begins and remains digital from camcorder to computer via FireWire cable. Analog degrades with each copy.
- The resolution of digital video is higher than analog because you can choose how many pixels, some of which offer as much as 410,000 or more pixels per CCD (charged couple devices). [xxx-link to “Getting to Know”] No matter what digital video format you choose, they all have excellent resolution quality. Although some digital formats have higher quality than others, the quality of analog can deteriorate only after 5 years.
- Analog recordings are highly susceptible to deterioration. Although a regular camcorder with analog may be cheaper in price, it is imperative to use digital video so that preservation of your video lasts and remains in the best condition.
Choosing A
Digital Format Next, you want to choose a digital video format.
In general, each type of cassette or disc is
made to record video using a particular
standard. For example, MiniDV cassettes record
video using the popular DV standard or
high-definition HDV, while discs and Microdrives
save MPEG-2 video. The design and the features
of the camcorder affect what you can do with the
video once it's shot. Thankfully, regardless of
the type of digital format you choose, you can
still enjoy unlimited copies of editing without
a decline in quality. Listed are examples of
formats accepted by HomeMovie.Com:
Professional Formats
- Digital S, DVCPRO & DVCAM
- Although they are all digital
formats, not all are compatible
- DVCAM accepts video tapes with a
MiniDV format
- Digital S has a higher
quality than DVCPRO o DVCAM & DVCPRO
are pretty much the same, depending on
what type of camcorder you purchase
- DVCPRO
is made for professional videographers
who specialize in taping big events such
as weddings.
- DVCPRO maximum camera
upload:
- 63 minutes with models
AJ-D400, 610, 700 and 810
- 123 minutes
with models AJ-D200 and 210
- 184
minutes with model AJ-D410
**Newer formats will hold 184 minutes
- DVCAM
maximum camera upload:
|
Most
Popular Format
- MiniDV
- Introduced by Sony in 1995
- First to come out with MiniDV
camcorder
- Cheapest of the digital formats
- Is the most reliable and most
commonly used by the average
consumer
- Has a maximum camera upload of
80 to 120 minutes
- Has very good digitizing quality
Formats NOT Recommended
- MiniDVD
- Low bit rate
- Highly susceptible to breakage
- Delamination and DVD rot
- Can only be played on certain
DVD players
|
Other Accepted Formats
- Digital 8
- Widely accepted format from
Sony. Great if you have an 8mm Sony
camcorder
- Bridge between DV (digital
video) and analog recording
- Recording format uses DV
compression to store data digitally
on a 8mm tape
- Maximum camera upload is only 60
minutes
- Is the medium between Hi8 and
MiniDV
- MicroMV
- Small & compact o Good playback
quality
- Less tape surface in the
cartridge than MiniDV cassette
- Requires more compression of the
video data than other formats
- Not as effective bitrate as
Digital 8 or MiniDV
|
Choosing Your Tripod
Purchasing a tripod for your camcorder is a very
good investment once you start feeling
comfortable shooting video. If you don’t want a
shaky picture, a tripod is the way to go. Next
time you are at a family function, try putting
your camcorder on a tripod. You’ll spend less
time, energy and concentration on your video. As
we discussed in "Shooting
During Vacation Time", if on vacation and
you don’t have access to a tripod, screw your
camcorder to the top of a lampshade in your
hotel room. This works with the majority of
camcorders. Consider these points when choosing
a tripod:
- Make sure to buy a model that is for
video, not still photography
- Make sure you purchase a tripod that can
withstand the weight of the camcorder plus
the weight of the battery
- Make sure that the tripod has a
quick-release mounting plate. Keep this in
good condition since they can crack and wear
over time
- You will have to decide if you want the
legs of the tripod to be quick-release or
the type with a thumb screw tightener
- Look for a tripod where you can extend
the center post on which the camcorder is
mounted. This allows you to adjust the
height without having to extend the legs.
- If you shoot a lot of video with
scenery, buying a high quality tripod with a
fluid head is key for panning landscapes and
panoramic shots.
- The last point to consider is buying a
tripod bag. This will help keep it in good
condition as well as making it more
convenient to transport.
A good resource for tripods:
Some Models Worth Considering:
3433 Fluid Head
755B MDVD Video Tripod
522A Sony LANC Remote
700RC2, 756BK MDVE Tripod with head
714B Digi Tripod
What Kind of User Am I?
When recording video, users often record similar
events. For example, one family might enjoy
taping their daughter’s dance recitals, while
another family might enjoy taping record their
son’s basketball games. Here are some examples
of the many different ways you can use your
camcorder:
- Sports and action
- Vacations and getaways
- Children’s first words, steps
and/or birthdays
- Holiday activities and
get-togethers
- Graduations
- Anniversaries
- Family interviews
- Recitals & plays
- Weddings
Features
to Consider Depending on how much you
want to spend on a digital camcorder,
there are many options available to fit
your price range. When selecting your
camcorder, remember these options:
-
Lens
quality—when purchasing a
camcorder, the size of the lens
determines the degree of light and
image quality. The larger the lens,
the better both of these qualities
will be when going on that family
vacation or taking video of your
brother’s wedding.
- Pixels—Pixels are the
number of dots that together
comprise a picture. The more pixels
in a fixed image, the greater the
resolution quality. High-quality
digital video camcorders offer as
much as 410,000 or more pixels per
CCD (What
is CCD?)
- Audio Options—To allow
for quality recording, HomeMovie.Com
recommends that you purchase a
camcorder that is able to record
audio using XLR balanced-type
microphones. With new features on
our Afiniti 3.0 player, audio plays
an important role in deciding which
model to purchase.
- Microphone connector—You
should look for the option of
connecting an external microphone.
Most models have a standard
mini-jack connector for an external
microphone. Some high-end models
have a 3-pin XLR connector,
sometimes called a balanced audio
connector.
- Resolution—When looking
at specification sheets to compare
features and pricing, some list
lines of resolution, other list the
number of pixels (410,000 pixels). A
good way to gauge this is to think
that more is better when comparing
resolution between camcorders.
- Image Stabilization—This
feature keeps video images stable
while shooting in an action
situation such as a sporting event.
Depending on the model you choose,
you will find either an optical
system or an electronic system. An
optical system is best and the
highest quality method. With an
optical system, there is no loss of
image quality and is also effective
in photo mode when shooting still
pictures.
- Optical vs. Digital Zoom—Most
cameras have both optical zoom and
digital zoom. Optical zoom works
just like a zoom lens on a film
camera. The lens changes focal
length and magnification as it is
zoomed. Image quality stays high
throughout the zoom range. Digital
zoom simply crops the image to a
smaller size, and then enlarges the
cropped portion to fill the frame
again. Digital zoom results in a
significant loss of quality as is
clear from the examples below. It's
pretty much a last resort, and if
you don't have it in camera, you can
do a similar job using almost any
image-editing program.
HomeMovie.Com wants you to have
the most ideal movie making
experience possible. Although there
are many digital video camcorders to
choose from, there is sure to be one
out there that will fit your needs!
Reviews as
of May 2006 |
BUDGET |
|
Low-Level ($300-$500) |
Mid-Level ($500-$800) |
| Product |
Price |
Score |
Product |
Price |
Score |
|
|
| Cnet |
1. Canon ZR 600 |
$317 |
6.6 |
1. Sony DCR- DVD405 |
$667 |
7.6 |
|
2. Canon ZR 100 |
$355 |
5.8 |
2. Sony Handycam DCR-HC96 |
$699 |
7.1 |
|
3. JVC GR-D396 |
$392 |
N/A |
3. Sanyo Xacti VPC-HD1 |
$729 |
7.0 |
|
4. Canon Optura 50 |
$445 |
6.9 |
4. Panasonic VDR-D300 |
$769 |
7.3 |
| |
|
|
5. Sony DCR-DVD 505 |
$877 |
7.5 |
|
|
|
NY Times |
1. Sony DCR-HC32 |
$399 |
6.8 |
1.
Panasonic PV-GS300 |
$547 |
6.6 |
| 2. JVC GR-DF550 |
$399 |
6.6 |
2. Canon
Optura S1 |
$579 |
6.8 |
| 3. Hitachi
DZMV-550A |
$399 |
7.0 |
3. JVC
Everio GZ MG27 |
$629 |
6.6 |
| 4. Panasonic PV-GS65 |
$463 |
7.5 |
4. Sony
DCR-HC90 |
$748 |
7.0 |
5. Sony Handycam
DCR-H32 |
$499 |
7.2 |
5. Sony
DCR-TRV22 |
$799 |
7.6 |
|
|
|